DeepSummary
The episode features an in-depth interview with prosecutor Matt Murphy about the case of Ed Shin, who was convicted of murdering his business partner Chris Smith. Murphy explains how Shin's gambling addiction and financial troubles provided a motive for him to kill Smith to avoid paying back $700,000 he owed. He describes the evidence gathered, including bloodstains at Shin's office and Smith's abandoned belongings, that contradicted Shin's story about Smith sailing off into the sunset.
Murphy recounts the key moment in the trial when he confronted Shin about faking emotions while testifying about the emails he sent to Smith's family suggesting he had committed suicide, emails calculated to mislead them about his fate. He also discusses Shin's refusal to reveal the location of Smith's body, likely to avoid further incriminating forensic evidence being uncovered.
The episode delves into Murphy's experiences as a prosecutor on these types of no-body murder cases and the gratification he derived from securing justice for victims' families like the Smiths. It also touches on Murphy's new book, TV work, and views on California's criminal justice policies that he sees as too lenient on serious offenders.
Key Episodes Takeaways
- Ed Shin killed his business partner Chris Smith, staged his disappearance, and misled Smith's family to avoid repaying $700,000 he owed.
- Prosecutor Matt Murphy's meticulous investigation uncovered physical evidence and exposed Shin's lies in a gripping courtroom confrontation.
- Shin's gambling addiction and financial troubles provided a motive, while his cold-blooded actions contrast with Smith's likable personality.
- Delivering justice for victims' loved ones like the Smiths gave Murphy immense professional satisfaction in an often emotionally draining career.
- Despite facing life in prison, Shin still refuses to reveal where he disposed of Smith's body, likely to avoid further incriminating forensic details.
- California's policies aimed at reducing harsh sentences concern Murphy as potentially benefiting remorseless murderers like Shin.
- Murphy found a post-prosecution career applying his skills in legal analysis, trial advocacy, and television commentary.
- The case underscores the darker societal risks of fraud and deception when coupled with greed and moral bankruptcy.
Top Episodes Quotes
- “The jury can always see the soul of your victim reflected in the eyes of those who love them so.“ by Matt Murphy
- “Sir, were you tearing up when you wrote that email to Debbie Smith saying their son was committing suicide or suggesting that he was going to do that? Were you tearing up when you did that?“ by Matt Murphy
- “Teared up a little bit right now. I'm okay.“ by Ed Shin
- “You don't dial 911 because you knew that if he died, you got his money. Isn't that true?“ by Matt Murphy
Entities
Company
Person
Product
Book
Broadcast
Episode Information
The Megyn Kelly Show
SiriusXM
6/11/24