DeepSummary
The podcast episode discusses the ongoing battle between the Seminole Tribe of Florida and the Smithsonian's National Museum of Natural History over the repatriation of around 1,500 Native American remains excavated from Florida. Tina Osceola, a member of the Seminole Tribe, has been fighting for over a decade to have these remains returned to Florida, as keeping them in the museum's storage facility goes against the tribe's beliefs about honoring the dead.
The episode traces the history of how these remains ended up in the museum's possession, highlighting the practice of archaeologists and scientists digging up Native American graves for research purposes, which was commonplace for centuries. Despite laws passed in the late 20th century requiring the repatriation of Native remains, the Natural History Museum has been slow to return them, citing difficulties in establishing cultural affiliation between the remains and present-day tribes.
The episode explores the debate around cultural affiliation standards, with the museum arguing for strict evidence-based criteria, while the Seminole Tribe believes their oral traditions and beliefs should be given weight. After public pressure from the tribe, the museum recently changed its policy to allow for the potential return of remains even without clear cultural affiliation, offering hope for the Seminoles' ongoing efforts.
Key Episodes Takeaways
- The Seminole Tribe of Florida has been engaged in a decade-long battle to reclaim around 1,500 Native American remains from the Smithsonian's National Museum of Natural History.
- These remains were excavated from Florida by archaeologists and scientists over many decades, reflecting a historical practice of digging up Native graves for research purposes.
- While laws were passed in the late 20th century mandating the repatriation of Native remains, the Natural History Museum has been slow to comply, citing difficulties in establishing cultural affiliation between the remains and present-day tribes like the Seminoles.
- The museum's cultural affiliation standards, which prioritize strict scientific evidence over oral traditions, have been a major point of contention with the Seminole Tribe, who believe their beliefs and ancestry should be given more weight.
- After public pressure from the tribe, the museum recently changed its policy to potentially allow for the return of remains without clear cultural affiliation, offering new hope for the Seminoles' repatriation efforts.
- The episode highlights the complex ethical issues surrounding the excavation and retention of Native remains, as well as the ongoing struggles of indigenous communities to reclaim their ancestral history and heritage.
- Differing perspectives on cultural affiliation and the role of scientific authority versus indigenous beliefs lie at the heart of this prolonged conflict.
- The repatriation of Native remains is seen by many tribes as a matter of respect for the dead and a crucial part of their cultural identity and practices.
Top Episodes Quotes
- “We're going to draw the line in the sand. We want them all back.“ by Tina Osceola
- “For more than a century. What it meant to be a good archaeologist was to dig things up to then preserve them forever.“ by Chip Caldwell
- “Once we receive something, we hold onto them and we don't get rid of them.“ by Bill Bilik
- “There is no objective standard.“ by Chip Caldwell
Entities
Company
Product
Podcast
Organization
Person
Book
Production
Episode Information
Code Switch
NPR
10/19/22
Learn more about sponsor message choices: podcastchoices.com/adchoices
NPR Privacy Policy