DeepSummary
Jordan Harbinger is joined by Jason Feifer, editor-in-chief of Entrepreneur magazine, to discuss the history and impact of participation trophies. Jason explains that contrary to popular belief, participation trophies have been around for over a century, originating after World War I as a way to encourage kids to participate in sports without the pressure of winning. While critics argue that they teach kids the wrong lesson about receiving rewards without effort, Jason contends that there is no scientific evidence of this, and kids naturally grow out of caring about participation trophies as they get older and become more interested in winning.
Jason argues that the debate around participation trophies stems from deeper anxieties about parenting, work ethic, and generational divides. He reveals how newspapers from as early as the 1920s celebrated participation trophies as a way to build self-esteem and a love for sports, challenging the notion that they are a modern phenomenon ruining kids. The discussion highlights that success comes in many forms, and an open, nuanced mindset is required rather than black-and-white thinking.
As a business expert, Jason is interested in the psychology behind what motivates people towards success. He believes the participation trophy debate has been oversimplified, and the trophies themselves are not inherently harmful - it's about understanding complex motivations and appreciating context. The key is embracing change, learning from failures, and recognizing that winning takes different paths for different people.
Key Episodes Takeaways
- Participation trophies have existed for over a century, originating after World War I as a way to encourage youth participation in sports without excessive pressure.
- There is no scientific evidence that participation trophies are harmful to child development or teach kids they don't need to put in effort.
- The debate around participation trophies stems more from generational anxieties around parenting, work ethic, and shifting values than the trophies themselves.
- Success takes many forms and paths - an open, nuanced mindset is required rather than binary, black-and-white thinking about winning and losing.
- Appreciating context and learning from failures is crucial for motivating success, rather than oversimplifying the influence of a single factor like trophies.
- As kids mature, they naturally become more interested in winning and less motivated by participation trophies alone.
- The visceral negativity towards participation trophies is a relatively recent phenomenon, contradicting claims that they are a new, corrupting influence.
- Debates like these highlight the tendency for people to treat old concepts as new developments and scapegoat them for modern societal anxieties.
Top Episodes Quotes
- “We've got enough participation trophies now. We'd like to get a place trophy.“ by A local girls softball coach
- “True success requires an open mind and complex thinking and an appreciation of what comes before and a realistic assessment of what might happen next.“ by Jason Feifer
- “You finish last, you come home with a trophy. You kidding me? I mean, what's that teaching kids it's okay to lose? And unfortunately, it's our society. It's what we're building for. And it's not just in basketball, it's in life.“ by Jeff Walz
Entities
Company
Person
Product
Book
Episode Information
The Jordan Harbinger Show
Jordan Harbinger
6/30/24
Are participation trophies ruining kids? Jason Feifer debunks myths and reveals the surprising century-long history behind the debate on Skeptical Sunday!
Welcome to Skeptical Sunday, a special edition of The Jordan Harbinger Show where Jordan and a guest break down a topic that you may have never thought about, open things up, and debunk common misconceptions. This time around, we're joined by Jason Feifer, the editor in chief of Entrepreneur magazine, host of the Build for Tomorrow podcast, and author of Build for Tomorrow: An Action Plan for Embracing Change, Adapting Fast, and Future-Proofing Your Career.
On This Week's Skeptical Sunday:
- As it turns out, participation trophies aren't some newfangled millennial invention. These shiny symbols of showing up have been collecting dust on shelves since your great-grandpappy was in short pants. We're talking 1922, folks — when the biggest participation trophy was surviving the Spanish Flu!
- All of these folks bellyaching about participation trophies probably have a few lurking in their own attics. It's like complaining about kids these days and their gimmicky rock music while air-guitaring to Led Zeppelin. Pot, meet kettle — you're both made of participation trophy material.
- Despite what the armchair psychologists down at the local watering hole might tell you, there's no scientific evidence that participation trophies turn kids into snowflakes. As they grow, kids naturally get more interested in winning than just showing up — like trading in their tricycle for a Harley.
- The whole participation trophy hullabaloo is less about plastic awards and more about our collective freak-out over parenting, work ethic, and why these darn kids won't get off our lawns. It's just generational anxiety dressed up in a well-worn, borrowed suit.
- Want to level up your success game? Ditch the black-and-white thinking. Winning's got more flavors than Baskin-Robbins, so keep an open mind for what's possible. Embrace the past, eye the future, and you'll be batting home runs with life's curveballs like a pro.
- Connect with Jordan on Twitter, Instagram, and YouTube. If you have something you'd like us to tackle here on Skeptical Sunday, drop Jordan a line at jordan@jordanharbinger.com and let him know!
- Connect with Jason Feifer at his website, Twitter, Instagram, and