DeepSummary
David Puder welcomes Dr. Eric Bender, a psychiatrist and psychotherapist, to discuss the podcast 'The Shrink Next Door' and the depiction of psychiatrists and therapists in media. They begin by acknowledging the 'Goldwater rule,' which prohibits mental health professionals from diagnosing public figures they have not evaluated. They then delve into the topic of boundary violations in therapy, using 'The Shrink Next Door' as an example.
They discuss the dynamics of abuse, grooming, and cults, and how therapists can isolate and control patients, often fulfilling their own needs rather than serving the patient's best interests. Puder and Bender emphasize the importance of maintaining appropriate boundaries in therapy, such as avoiding business relationships or sexual contact with patients.
They also explore the portrayal of therapy in various media, highlighting both accurate and inaccurate depictions. Bender expresses his desire to create a television show that accurately represents good mental health practices and therapy, dispelling stigma and encouraging people to seek help.
Key Episodes Takeaways
- Mental health professionals must maintain appropriate boundaries and avoid exploiting or manipulating patients for their own needs.
- Good therapy should empower patients, increase their self-efficacy, and foster meaningful relationships outside of therapy.
- Accurate and responsible portrayals of therapy and mental health in media are important to dispel stigma and encourage people to seek help.
- Maintaining a clear frame and boundaries in therapy, such as respecting time limits, avoiding physical contact, and not involving family members, is crucial.
- Therapists should prioritize the patient's needs and growth, rather than fulfilling their own needs or agenda.
- Ongoing self-reflection and personal therapy for therapists are essential to provide ethical and effective treatment.
- Recognizing and addressing transference and countertransference dynamics is key to a healthy therapeutic relationship.
- Media depictions of therapy and mental health can influence public perception and should strive for accuracy and nuance.
Top Episodes Quotes
- “So in 1964, there was a magazine called Fact magazine, and at the time, they surveyed 12,356 psychiatrists around the country and asked whether those psychiatrists thought the candidate, Barry Goldwater, was mentally stable enough to hold office.“ by Eric Bender
- “So typically with a cult leader, what they'll do is they'll sense there's a vulnerability in a person, and they'll recognize that that person needs something emotionally, and they'll play on that.“ by Eric Bender
- “If we look at the depiction of a therapist, and the therapist is not helping a patient, but is serving himself or herself, or if we look at depictions of mental health and see people who are violent, we're going to assume certain things. And that's really damaging to people, both with mental health issues and people who are seeking help.“ by Eric Bender
- “But again, is the person getting something out of this that makes them feel like they're building something, but that you can objectively look at and say, yes, they're still building something. If not, then really, who's it for at this point? Are you just filling a block in your. In your schedule, or what is it that you're actually doing this for?“ by Eric Bender
- “I would love to get to a point where I can help people not be afraid of having emotions and sharing them with other people.“ by Eric Bender
Entities
Person
Organization
Movie
Tv show
Concept
Book
Episode Information
Psychiatry & Psychotherapy Podcast
David Puder, M.D.
7/4/24
Listening to The Shrink Next Door elicited a range of emotions in me, including angst, sadness, intrigue, and heartache. For those unfamiliar with the story, it revolves around a psychiatrist named Ike who isolates his patient, Marty, from his family, takes over his business, lives in his house, charges him over a million dollars, and makes him undertake various projects for him. We will discuss the podcast's characters as if they are fictional. The podcast, akin to House of Cards for the psychotherapy world, reveals the manipulation and betrayal that can occur behind the scenes. Just as House of Cards exposed viewers to the Machiavellian tactics in politics, The Shrink Next Door disrupts the sacred space of the therapy office.
This week, I am joined by Dr. Eric Bender, a psychiatrist and psychotherapist, to discuss, The Shrink Next Door. Dr. Bender practices in San Francisco, has been featured multiple times on GQ’s online show The Breakdown, Wired magazine’s Tech Help, and on YouTube.