The podcast episodes examine the history and evolution of the cattle mutilation phenomenon, tracing it back to the 1970s when these strange occurrences first gained widespread attention.

The episodes explore the various conspiracy theories and explanations that have been proposed to account for these incidents, including government experiments, Satanic cults, and extraterrestrial involvement. They also consider the more plausible scientific explanations for the mutilations.

Specific examples of the episodes' coverage of cattle mutilation can be found in Cattle Mutilation with Rachel Monroe on the 'You're Wrong About' podcast, and Skinwalker Ranch, Part I: The Sherman Era on the 'Haunted Cosmos' podcast.