The hosts share embarrassing stories from their pasts, such as Tara drinking old vinegar because a boy dared her to, and Jared's excessive milk consumption as a child.
The podcast episodes provided focus heavily on the topic of embarrassing stories, with various hosts and guests sharing their own cringeworthy experiences or reacting to stories submitted by listeners.
For example, in the episode Listener Jodie's Unfortunate Encounter With A Wig, the hosts discuss an embarrassing wig mix-up at the dentist, while in Faking Orgasms (w/ Stavros Halkias), the hosts share awkward hookup stories.
Embarrassing stories serve as a common theme across multiple podcast genres, from comedy podcasts like Chuckle Sandwich to relationship-focused shows like Boyfriend Material with Harry Jowsey.