A major theme is Hannity's accusation that the judge has exhibited bias in favor of the prosecution through actions like limiting defense evidence and giving improper jury instructions.
The podcast episodes discuss allegations of judicial bias in the cases against former President Donald Trump, with the hosts and guests accusing the presiding judges of exhibiting bias in favor of the prosecution.
For example, in the episode 'BONUS: Is the Trump Verdict a Witch Trial? Or Justice?', the episode examines the potential for judicial bias in the upcoming classified documents case before Judge Eileen Cannon, based on her previous rulings.
Similarly, the episode 'Failures of Biased Judge in Sham Trump Trial, with Alan Dershowitz and Mark Geragos | Ep. 805' criticizes Judge Juan Merchan's biased rulings in the Trump business records trial, accusing him of acting as a 'prosecutor in a robe'.
These allegations of judicial bias are further explored in episodes like 'Jury Requests Analyzed - May 29th, Hour 1', 'The Bongino Brief - The World Is Laughing at America', and 'Jack Smith vs. Trump Docs Case Judge, and Disturbing Rise of Assisted Suicide, with Mike Davis, Dave Aronberg, and Rupa Subramanya | Ep. 758', where the hosts and guests criticize the judges' conduct and decisions as being biased against the former president.