The MeatEater Trivia episodes of the MeatEater Podcast revolve around a trivia game show format, where the hosts and guests engage in friendly competition while answering questions on a variety of outdoor-related topics.

The episodes feature lively banter, debates, and the use of 'phone a friend' options as the participants test their knowledge on subjects like hunting, fishing, conservation, and cooking.

The winner of the trivia game often chooses a conservation-focused organization, like the Nature Conservancy or the Aldo Leopold Foundation, to receive a donation from MeatEater.