The podcast episodes discuss several instances of suspicious behavior, such as encounters with individuals exhibiting concerning actions or raising red flags that could signal potential danger.

For example, the episodes from Malevolent Mischief: True Stories of Horror Vol. 216 and Vol. 215 recount stories of Reddit users encountering suspicious individuals posing as helpers or salesmen, which serves as a warning about the importance of trusting one's instincts in such situations.

Similarly, the Crime Junkie episode on the mysterious death of Lauren Agee explores the suspicious behavior of her friends, which may have been indicative of their potential involvement in her death.