DeepSummary
The episode revolves around a 30-year-old rumor that Jane McDougall had an affair with hockey player Jeff Brown, allegedly causing the Vancouver Canucks' poor performance in the 1995 season after their successful Stanley Cup run in 1994. Despite being false, the rumor has persisted and affected Jane's life, with people constantly bringing it up.
Jane inherited the rumor after it initially involved Jeff Brown and Kirk McLean's ex-wife Leslie. Jane and Kirk started dating a few years later, and the rumor shifted to involve Jane instead. The rumor was fueled by fans seeking an explanation for the team's decline and found traction on online forums.
Through interviews with those involved, including Kirk McLean, Jeff Brown, and Leslie, the episode debunks the rumor and provides more plausible reasons for the Canucks' performance, such as the challenges of repeating success, coaching conflicts, and the nature of sports fandom. The episode explores why such rumors persist and the harmful effects they can have, particularly on women.
Key Episodes Takeaways
- The rumor about Jane McDougall having an affair with hockey player Jeff Brown, allegedly causing the Vancouver Canucks' poor performance in 1995, was entirely false.
- Despite being untrue, the rumor persisted for over 30 years, fueled by fans seeking an explanation for the team's decline and finding traction on online forums.
- The rumor had a significant impact on Jane McDougall's life, with people constantly bringing it up and affecting her reputation.
- The episode debunks the rumor and offers more plausible reasons for the Canucks' performance, such as the challenges of repeating success, coaching conflicts, and the nature of sports fandom.
- The episode highlights the harmful nature of unsubstantiated gossip and the unfair scrutiny and scapegoating women often face in such situations.
- Sports fandom and the desire for scandalous narratives contribute to the persistence of such rumors, despite a lack of evidence.
- The episode explores the broader implications of rumors and gossip, touching on themes of gender bias, human behavior, and the need for caution when spreading unsubstantiated claims.
- Jane McDougall's philosophical perspective on the rumor and her determination to clear her name serve as a powerful commentary on the importance of reputation and the resilience required to navigate such situations.
Top Episodes Quotes
- “I've spoken to my editors over the years about it, and they've said, why would you want to bring this up? And I keep thinking, because it's my reputation.“ by Jane McDougall
- “You know, I don't think people realize what it takes out of you to get that far and to be a professional athlete. There's a lot of pressure.“ by Kirk McLean
- “Maybe it's easier to believe that something pulls your favorite team apart than the fact that maybe the players just aren't as good as you thought they were. Or that it was lightning in a bottle in 1994, and that lightning has evaporated.“ by Mark Lewis
- “You are being judged, and you are being judged because we judge women very harshly for this.“ by Jane McDougall
Entities
Company
Person
Product
Organization
Podcast
Event
Episode Information
Decoder Ring
Slate Podcasts
6/19/24
30 years ago, the Stanley Cup playoffs ignited a rumor that has been messing with Jane Macdougall’s life ever since.
In 1994, the Vancouver Canucks had made it all the way to Game 7 of the Stanley Cup Finals against the New York Rangers. When they barely lost, fans expected the team to come back blazing the next year. Instead, 1995 was a total letdown. Team chemistry disappeared and fans started looking for an explanation. Quickly, a rumor took hold: a defensive player had been having an affair with the goalie’s wife, which destroyed team morale and left the franchise flailing.
In this episode of Decoder Ring, Acey Rowe from the Canadian Broadcasting Corporation traces the Canucks rumor from locker rooms to chat rooms. And she talks to NHL players Kirk McLean and Jeff Brown to figure out how a story like this can snowball and survive for 30 years.
This episode was reported and produced by Acey Rowe. Story editing by Willa Paskin and Evan Chung. Decoder Ring is produced by Willa Paskin, Evan Chung, Katie Shepherd and Max Freedman. Derek John is Executive Producer. Merritt Jacob is Senior Technical Director.
A longer version of this story was published on CBC’s Storylines, part of the CBC Audio Doc Unit. Julia Pagel is the Senior Producer of Audio Docs and Anna Lazowski is the Senior Producer of Special Programming at the CBC.
If you have a cultural mystery you’d like us to decode send us an email at decoderring@slate.com. Please subscribe and rate our feed in Apple Podcasts or wherever you listen. And even better, tell your friends.
If you’re a fan of the show, you should sign up for Slate Plus. Members get to listen to Decoder Ring and all other Slate podcasts without any ads and have total access to Slate’s website. Your support is also crucial to our work. Go to Slate.com/decoderplus to join Slate Plus today.
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices