DeepSummary
The episode features an interview with Annie McClanahan, an assistant professor of English at UC Irvine, discussing the history and current state of the service and tip work economies. McClanahan explains how technological advancements have led to the deskilling and automation of labor, particularly in service industries, resulting in low wages and precarious employment conditions for workers.
McClanahan delves into the historical roots of the subminimum wage for tipped workers, tracing it back to the Fair Labor Standards Act of 1938 and the subsequent amendments that created the tip credit wage. She highlights the role of powerful lobbying groups like the National Restaurant Association in shaping these policies, which have kept tipped workers' wages stagnant for decades.
The conversation explores the broader implications of technological stagnation in service work, its impact on economic growth, and the possibility of imagining a world disentangled from the wage system. McClanahan shares her vision for finding new forms of solidarity and resistance among workers across different sectors, challenging the dominant narratives that perpetuate the exploitation of labor.
Key Episodes Takeaways
- The service and tip work economies have a long history rooted in the exclusion and exploitation of marginalized groups, such as women, people of color, and immigrants.
- Technological advancements in service industries have led to the deskilling and automation of labor, resulting in low wages, precarious employment conditions, and increased alienation for workers.
- The subminimum wage for tipped workers, established through the Fair Labor Standards Act and subsequent amendments, has been shaped by powerful lobbying groups like the National Restaurant Association, keeping wages stagnant for decades.
- The cyclical relationship between technological stagnation and low wages in service work incentivizes the continued exploitation of marginalized workers, as companies prioritize cost-saving over innovation.
- Challenging the dominant narratives surrounding work, productivity, and economic growth is crucial for envisioning a world disentangled from the wage system and finding new forms of solidarity among workers across different sectors.
- Examining the material and ideological factors that contribute to the devaluation of service work, such as the feminization of labor, is essential for understanding the broader issues of exploitation and inequality.
- Platforms like Amazon Mechanical Turk exemplify the alienation and lack of agency experienced by workers in the gig economy, where the nature of their labor is obscured by algorithms and they have little understanding of the larger context or impact of their work.
- Annie McClanahan's work highlights the need for a critical analysis of the regulatory and political histories that have shaped the service and tip work economies, challenging the traditional focus on affect and emotion in cultural studies of service work.
Top Episodes Quotes
- “Even if you could develop a machine for taking out trash cans, it's probably not worth it, because that technology is probably going to be more expensive to develop and maintain than the incredibly low wages that you can pay a human being, particularly a woman of color, let's say, or an immigrant, to do the same job. So there's this kind of like, twinned dynamic around service work where technological stagnation leads to low wages and low wages incentivize technological stagnation.“ by Annie McClanahan
- “The first thing that happened was that I was writing a little bit about service work and in person service work, and I was thinking a lot about tips and the history of tipping and started to do a lot of research on that and sort of thinking about the ways in which tip work relates to the problem of how do you produce what's called time discipline in service work?“ by Annie McClanahan
- “The problem with that, from the position, from the perspective of workers still trapped in a wage economy, is that service work tends to be low waged. The reason that it tends to be low waged is, I mean, there's a lot of factors that some of them are sort of ideological, so they have to do with the feminization of labor.“ by Annie McClanahan
Entities
Company
Person
Product
Organization
Book
Episode Information
Green Dreamer: Seeding change towards collective healing, sustainability, regeneration
Kamea Chayne
7/5/22
“Under a capitalist system of production or any system of production based on the extraction of value via wages, it’s always going to be the case that mechanization leads to more work and lower wages...”
In this episode, we welcome Annie McClanahan, an Assistant Professor of English at UC Irvine, where she is also a faculty advisor for UCI-LIFTED, a prison education program. Her first book, Dead Pledges: Debt, Crisis, and 21st Century Culture, was published in 2016, and she is currently finishing a second book, Tipwork, Gigwork, Microwork: Culture and the Wages of Service.
Some of the topics we explore in this conversation include the history of today's service and tip work economies, the trend of automation driving deskilled labor and microwork, the possibility of a world disentangled from wages, and more.
(The musical offering featured in this episode is Come The Rain by Maggie Clifford. The episode-inspired artwork is by Ellie Yanagisawa.)
Support our in(ter)dependent show: GreenDreamer.com/support