The podcast episodes provided showcase a range of paranormal and supernatural themes, from discussions of potential demonic possession or otherworldly entities ('My Wife's Been Peeking At Me Around Corners | Creep Cast'), to stories of mysterious creatures like the 'Michigan Dogman' (464 | Dogman ATTACK in Manistee National Forest | 8 TRUE Michigan HORROR Stories).

The Magnus Archives podcast also hints at larger paranormal or supernatural elements at play around the Magnus Institute, an organization dedicated to researching the esoteric and weird (The Magnus Protocol 2 - Making Adjustments).

Additionally, the 'You're Wrong About' podcast episode discusses a collaboration with the 'American Hysteria' podcast to explore 'sensational otherworldly beliefs' through a live event featuring a 'massive séance' (A MASSIVE SÉANCE with American Hysteria in Portland, Oregon).