DeepSummary
In this episode, Breht analyzes and criticizes a podcast conversation between Sam Harris and Yale historian Timothy Snyder about the Russia-Ukraine war. He argues that Snyder fails to substantively address arguments made by dissident thinkers about NATO's provocations, the need for de-escalation, and America's role in the conflict. Breht accuses Harris of promoting a liberal, pro-American perspective and dismissing valid critiques from the far-left.
Breht also dissects a clip from another podcast featuring a young Cuban-American woman who expresses gratitude for the 'freedoms' she has in America after her family fled the 'communist dictatorship' of Cuba. However, Breht points out the irony in her statement as she describes experiences of lacking healthcare, being homeless, and the trauma of a school shooting - issues that are largely non-existent in Cuba.
Throughout the episode, Breht vehemently criticizes American exceptionalism and the notion that the US is morally superior to other countries like Russia or Cuba. He argues that America's long history of imperialism, violence, and oppression make it morally inferior, and suggests that the revolutionary traditions of countries like Cuba are more deserving of pride.
Key Episodes Takeaways
- Breht argues that Sam Harris and the Yale historian Timothy Snyder fail to substantively address critiques of America's role in provoking and escalating the Russia-Ukraine conflict.
- Breht accuses liberal perspectives of promoting American exceptionalism and moral superiority, which he vehemently rejects.
- Breht points out the irony of a Cuban-American woman expressing gratitude for American 'freedoms' after her family fled Cuba, while describing lack of access to healthcare, housing, education and safety in America.
- Breht argues that America's long history of violence, imperialism and oppression makes it morally inferior to countries like Cuba, contrary to American propaganda.
- Breht suggests that the revolutionary traditions and achievements of countries like Cuba in providing healthcare, housing and education as rights are more deserving of pride than American 'freedoms'.
- Breht criticizes the notion that Russia's actions are irrational, arguing instead that Putin is acting rationally from Russia's perceived security interests, even if Breht disagrees with the justifications.
- Breht condemns attempts to portray far-left critiques of American imperialism as morally equivalent to fascism or anti-Semitism.
- Breht expresses hope that the younger generation's political consciousness will continue developing towards anti-capitalist and anti-imperialist perspectives.
Top Episodes Quotes
- “I didn't have healthcare my entire life, pretty much. I grew up with a single mom. So going to the doctor was always a thing of, is it really urgent? Can you wait? Is this something that we can fix at home?“ by Unidentified Speaker
- “Even now, I kind of have to tell myself, go to the doctor. But also in high school, I experienced homelessness for a few months with my mom, and that was something that took a really big toll on my mental health.“ by Unidentified Speaker
- “I fled a communist dictatorship. I came to America, my parents told me, thank God we're here. We have all the freedoms. And then I experienced fucking homelessness and school shootings and not having access to healthcare and having to pay tens of thousands of dollars coming from a poor single mother home for a higher education.“ by Breht
Entities
Book
Person
Organization
Episode Information
Revolutionary Left Radio
Revolutionary Left Radio
10/27/22
In this episode, Breht plays clips of, and responds to, a recent podcast put out by Sam Harris and Yale Historian Timothy Snyder on the Russia-Ukraine war in which they advance several liberal, pro-american criticisms against dissident thinkers on the topic. Then Breht plays a clip from a NYT podcast about Cuba and launches into a classic Red Hot Take style rant on the topic.
Outro music by Kodak Black
Support Rev Left Radio: https://www.patreon.com/RevLeftRadio